Pranav 5 hours ago Sir tell me one thing. Harshad Bhai's famous strategy was cost replacement theory. Like what was the initial cost of setting up the company and factory and in future what will be the cost required to setup the same business with that much scale. So that is the true value of company. Which can help us track the intrinsic value of the business. This what he did with Acc, polo steels. Is it possible to value the cos this way in this era. Also what is your view was he a good. stock picker or else he was a good speculator. Or do we require speculations angle to take the stocks up. Just for understanding. My Reply- to all - Please read Pranav question too. He is running after full proof plan. He is in a confused state of mind. Should I do replacement theory, should I do speculation with it? What should I do? I have said here many times, each stock is different. But he read but ignored it. I said here many times, don't use same yardstick for all stocks. He read but ignored. All stock while analyzing has different Merits. He read but he ignored. He don't want to learn. He only want to ask questions. Just for the sake of asking. Because if he has learned something, his query was not necessary This is too much for me. I have explained to him many times this same thing, read again what I have written above. Keep reading, Pranav, untill you learn by heart what I have wrtitten ABOVE , because this will be the last time I will be giving you reply of same Nature. I can't keep explaining you same thing again and again. This happened with surendra55 member. He was ditto like you. Uske demag main bhi jo batata tha, jata hi nahi tha. I have to terminate his subscription. Hope I have not to do with you the same thing. And last , don't be oversmart to write, just for understanding. I know what you are doing!!